you're reading...

No Apologies or Apologists Necessary: How we all are Superman

No Apologies or Apologists Necessary

                How often, we are polarized by our politics, our economics, or morality.  The conversation in which we hope to achieve, both intellectually and informatively, is often lost among the clouds of chatter and discontent.  Let us remember, and let us begin, hopefully never to end, with the recognition that apologies and apologists are not necessary. 

                This is not to suggest that we never believe that we are wrong in our assertions, assumptions or beliefs, or that we should not seek comfort in others who can bond and connect, humanize with our faults, both educationally and personally.  However, we have no need for apologies for our approach, to stand firm in it, to be courageous, confident and willing to obtain objects regardless of others judgments or lack of faith.  Neither should we rely, associate or join in some sort of an apologist’s behavior that zaps responsibility away from each of us. 

                 I have not seen the film Waiting for Superman, but while I may see it, I don’t have to, to already have a formulated opinion, not only about the movie, the reviews by educators, or my own educational solutions.  You see, the polarization is baked right into the title, intended to separate us, politically, economically, philosophically.  However, it is not that superman exists in the teacher unions or in the charter school leaders, in the principals of the public school or the head master of the private institutions, no, see there is not waiting, because superman, his cape, his creative solutions and kindness exists in each of us. We are superman.  Until this is understood, he will continue to be whisked away under a cloak of suspicion, distrust and disillusionment.

                Deep down, many educators are actually working for the same things, their heart, mostly, is in the right space and for the right reasons.  Whether they are exposed to the ways that work best or not, is based on experience, intellectual curiosity, and interactions, but deep down, educators of all beliefs and variety want the same thing:  The best way for students to learn.  We might have different ways to get to that common goal and how to achieve that common goal, but we still have that common goal.  So we must be confident in that, we must not apologize for that common belief, the arguments and debates can and will continue and divisiveness will not end, but if we start from that notion, how remarkably similar we will become. 

Let us not be apologists for others, who do not do this, for the progressive educator who does not spend enough time on lesson plans as on theory, or the private school teacher who believes discipline is the best way to achieve specific educational marks, or the public school teacher whose hard work and heart are in the right spot, but who are blinded to the systematic concerns that harm the same students they are trying desperately to help.   

You see, it is not left vs. right, or even right vs. wrong, but rather a common, passionate bond, that is often lost in the day to day grind of finally deepening and truly understanding the concept of learning.  We must critically examine ourselves, walk miles in others shoes, and remember above all else, that education and learning involves all of us and makes each of us the true Superman.

About caseykcaronna

A 27 year old Master of Arts in Education Degree holder from the progressive, liberal arts school, Goddard College. I am interested in Holistic, Community, Progressive, Democratic and Student-Centered Education. I am currently a part-time employee with the Boy Scouts of America. I am writing my first book on holistic education and looking for full time employment in education, throughout the United States and Canada. I am interested in all things education and hope to make trans-formative changes to the educational system(s) in America and in the process help to improve the lives of the individuals in whom it serves.


3 thoughts on “No Apologies or Apologists Necessary: How we all are Superman

  1. Casey, I love the sentiment here. @edReformer, @JasonFlom and I were tweeting last night about strange it is that people with such similar desires should take issue with one another in so many ways. There is common ground we can’t lose sight of in trampling over it, charging towards “them” or our visions of the future.

    Your call for compassion resonates with me. We need a dialogue more that looks more like a coffee shop and less like a court or op-ed page.

    I might not be the guy for such a centrist effort (at least not online; lean a little over this way, everybody!), but I see the need for it and potential for cooperation. I will try to be helpful defining one end of the many reform/transform spectra.

    What kinds of tools and channels would you use to bring together the reactionaries, iconoclasts, and everyone in between? A local TEDx event? An unconference? A website? A movie?


    Posted by Chad Sansing | October 12, 2010, 4:16 pm
  2. Hi Casey, I’m really with you on the sentiment here. One of the ways we tap out our important energies as educators is by fighting with each other over exquisitely precious ground, when we all actually probably agree on much more than we’re battling about. This has to do with our sense of being embattled, misunderstood, underappreciated. We’re ready to get up in someone’s face and fight for our point of view as a first impulse–then listen only later. Maybe.

    One of the ironies of Waiting For Superman is that the point of the movie is that there is no Superman. Geoffrey Canada describes his sense of disappointment, right in the middle of the film, when he realized as an elementary school kid that “no one was coming to save us,” that no one had the power to do that. That’s actually what the movie is about. No superheros. Just us.

    Posted by Kirsten | October 14, 2010, 9:16 am
  3. I love your take on it. I agree that the polarization is a part of the problem.

    Posted by John Spencer | October 18, 2010, 5:09 pm

Join the Conversation

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 4,100 other followers

Comments are subject to moderation.

%d bloggers like this: